Are you struggling with a stubborn pooch that just won't listen? Discover the top picks for the best training collars for stubborn dogs in 2023.

Mastering Obedience: The Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs

Training stubborn dogs can be a challenge, but with the right tools and understanding, it’s possible to turn even the most headstrong canine into a well-behaved companion. In this blog post, we’ll explore the reasons behind stubborn dog behavior, introduce the best training collar for stubborn dogs, and share expert tips on using these collars effectively. Get ready to embark on a journey towards better communication and a stronger bond with your furry friend!

Key Takeaways

  • Understanding the root causes of stubborn dog behavior is essential to finding an effective training solution.
  • Consider factors such as requirements, temperament and safety features when choosing a training collar for your pet.
  • Training collars can be used responsibly with positive reinforcement techniques to effectively train a stubborn dog.

Understanding Stubborn Dog Behavior

A professional dog trainer demonstrating how to use a dog training collar on a stubborn dog

Understanding the motivations behind a canine’s stubbornness is the first step in exploring the world of dog training collars. Genetics, environment, and past experiences can all contribute to a dog’s stubborn behavior, affecting the effectiveness of remote dog training collars. Maintaining consistency is key when training a stubborn dog, as dogs thrive on routine and may become disoriented if their training lacks continuity, leading to a decreased likelihood of responding to commands.

Alternative training methods and collars for stubborn dogs include martingale or head collars, positive reinforcement, and consistent clear commands. Moreover, modern shock collars come with various training options beyond just shock or electric stimulation, making them more humane and versatile for addressing stubborn behavior in dogs of all sizes and temperaments.

Top 5 Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs in 2023

In 2024, the top 5 training collars for stubborn dogs are:

  1. SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers
  2. Mini Educator ET-300 Remote Training Collar by E-Collar Technologies
  3. PetSafe Remote Training Collar
  4. Dogtra ARC Handsfree Remote Training Collar
  5. SportDog 425X Field Trainer Remote Training Collar

Each of these best dog training collars offers unique features and benefits designed to cater to different training needs, ensuring the safety and comfort of your dog while providing effective training results.

Advanced E-Collar with Multiple Modes

E-collars are available with a variety of features, such as vibration, sound and light. These can be used together with electrical stimulation for added effect. These collars offer versatility in training and are especially useful for working with stubborn dogs that may require different types of correction to respond effectively. The advantage of an e-collar is its ability to be used from a distance, allowing for convenient training in large open spaces or while on hunting trips.

Assessing suitability for your dog’s size, breed, and sensitivity is a crucial factor when choosing an e-collar. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions to guarantee the proper usage and effectiveness of the collar, and consult a professional dog trainer if needed for additional guidance.

Long-Range Remote Training Collar

Long-range remote training collars are ideal for outdoor activities and off-leash training, with a range of up to one mile. A recommended range of 1,000 feet or more ensures optimal off-leash training and enables you to maintain control over your dog even in vast open spaces.

When selecting a remote dog training collar for outdoor activities, consider its durability and ability to withstand the elements. The PetSafe Remote Training Collar, for example, offers three distinct training modes: beep-only mode, vibration-only mode, and static stimulation mode, making it versatile and adaptable to different training situations.

Adjustable Intensity Shock Collar

boxer dog with adjustable intensity shock collar
Adjustable Intensity Shock Collar

Adjustable intensity shock collars provide varying levels of electric shock, allowing you to customize the intensity based on your dog’s size, temperament, and training needs. Static stimulation, a mild electric stimulation delivered through the collar, is intended to discourage unwanted behaviors and is often adjustable to suit the dog’s needs.

Training with an adjustable intensity shock collar can be tailored to your dog’s individual needs and sensitivity by adjusting the intensity levels according to their behavior and response. This ensures a more effective and humane training experience. Some shock collars also offer multiple training modes, such as vibration or beep, which can be used as alternatives to shocks for dogs with more sensitive temperaments.

Vibration and Tone-Based Training Collar

Vibration and tone-based training collars provide a more humane alternative to static stimulation, suitable for dogs with a more sensitive disposition. These collars utilize varying levels of vibration or beep/tone stimuli to serve as cues or warnings for training and to mark undesired behaviors.

Vibration and tone-based training collars offer several advantages over other types of training collars, including:

  • Enabling correction at longer distances
  • Addressing behavior issues when out of hearing range
  • Providing a more humane alternative to shock collars
  • Offering versatility in settings
  • Being effective for sensitive dogs

Customizable Training Collar for Large Dogs

The adjustable Petrainer dog training collar is designed to provide a comfortable fit for large stubborn dogs. It has the following features:

  • Adjustable settings to meet pet owners’ obedience training needs
  • A range of up to 330 yards
  • A neck size range of 6 to 23 inches
  • Three training modes: static stimulation, vibration, and tone options
  • 21 levels of static stimulation
  • Various accessories for versatile training

The adjustable training collar offers versatility, safety features, and customization to meet your dog’s specific training needs. Additionally, it is equipped with a flashlight and a night light feature, ensuring the safety and comfort of your pet during nighttime training sessions.

Expert Tips for Using Training Collars on Stubborn Dogs

A pet owner using a shock collar to train a stubborn dog
Expert Tips for Using Training Collars on Stubborn Dogs

Achieving optimal results when using training collars on stubborn dogs requires proper and consistent use of the collar, and professional assistance if needed. To apply a training collar to a stubborn dog, follow these steps:

  1. Place a non-metallic collar around the dog’s neck.
  2. Position the training collar above the non-metallic collar.
  3. Attach the training leash to the training collar.
  4. Ensure that the collar is properly fitted and secure.

Maintaining consistency is vital when using training collars for stubborn dogs. Apply the training collar’s stimuli or signals consistently whenever the dog displays undesirable behavior to help them comprehend the cause and effect relationship between their actions and the consequences. If no progress is being made or if there is uncertainty regarding the proper use of the collar, consider seeking professional help to ensure the safety and efficacy of the training.

Alternative Training Methods for Stubborn Dogs

A professional dog trainer demonstrating alternative training methods for stubborn dogs
Alternative Training Methods for Stubborn Dogs

If you’re hesitant to use a training collar or want to explore additional training options, consider investigating more humane and positive approaches, as well as consulting with a professional dog trainer or behaviorist specialist. Alternative methods for training stubborn dogs include positive reinforcement, clicker training, and the use of head collars or harnesses.

Consulting professionals can help dog owners determine the most suitable collar or training method for their particular dog and circumstances, especially for aggressive dogs. Prioritizing your dog’s well-being and safety while employing effective training methods will lead to a happier, more obedient canine companion.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Training Collar

remote dog training with collar
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Training Collar

When selecting a training collar, consider factors such as your particular requirements as a pet owner, the temperament of the dog, range, battery life, and robustness. Additionally, consider safety features such as an automatic shut-off after a certain duration and built-in safety measures when selecting a shock collar for large stubborn dogs.

Making sure that the training collar you choose is tailored to your dog’s size, breed, and sensitivity is crucial for proper training. Consulting with a professional trainer can offer guidance tailored to the individual needs of your dog and suggest appropriate options for achieving effective training results.

How to Train Your Stubborn Dog Using a Training Collar

husky dog on leash with his trainer
How to Train Your Stubbo

Training a stubborn dog using a training collar involves a step-by-step process that focuses on gradual familiarization, finding the minimal stimulation level, and rewarding desired behavior. Begin by introducing your dog to the collar, allowing them to wear it without any correction for a few days to ensure they are comfortable with it.

Next, find the minimal stimulation level your dog responds to by gradually increasing the collar’s intensity until your dog exhibits a subtle reaction, such as a head turn or ear twitch. This level should be the starting point for your training sessions, ensuring that the correction is noticeable but not causing undue distress.

When using a training collar, it’s vital to apply the collar’s stimuli or signals consistently whenever your dog displays undesirable behavior.

Finally, reward your dog for displaying desired behavior, such as obeying a command or refraining from an unwanted action. This positive reinforcement will help your dog associate the correction from the training collar with their actions, resulting in more productive training results and a happier, more obedient dog.

Common Misconceptions About Training Collars

yellow dog training collar
Common Misconceptions About Training Collars

There are several misconceptions about dog training collars, including:

  • The belief that e-collars are used to punish dogs
  • The belief that they cause harm or discomfort
  • The belief that e-collar training will create fear in the dog towards the owner

In reality, training collars can be an effective tool for dog training when used properly and responsibly. They should not be employed as a punishment, but rather as a means of reinforcing desirable behaviors.

Prioritizing positive reinforcement training methods is crucial for ensuring the well-being and safety of dogs. By using training collars in combination with positive reinforcement techniques, pet owners can achieve effective and humane training results, ensuring the happiness and well-being of their canine companions.


In conclusion, training stubborn dogs can be a challenging yet rewarding experience, and with the right tools and understanding, even the most headstrong canine can become a well-behaved companion. By exploring the top training collars for stubborn dogs, learning about alternative training methods, and following expert tips, you can achieve effective and humane training results that will strengthen the bond between you and your furry friend. Embark on this journey with confidence, and watch as your stubborn dog transforms into an obedient and loving companion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do shock collars work for stubborn dogs?

While shock collars may seem like an easy solution for a stubborn pup, there are more effective and gentle alternatives such as martingales or head collars that can provide control without causing pain or fear. Educating yourself on the proper usage of e-collars and selecting the right training collar is key to successful dog training.

How do you train a super stubborn dog?

Training a super stubborn dog requires patience and consistency. Employ positive reinforcement with treats or toys to keep your pup motivated and focused. Be willing to invest the time and effort needed to achieve lasting results.

What collar is best for aggressive dogs?

Head Halters, Slip Leads, Martingale Collars, and Safety Collars are the best collars for aggressive dogs. Depending on your dogs behavior and temperament, finding the best dog collar for your pup is an important decision.

What factors contribute to a dog's stubborn behavior?

Genetics, environment, and past experiences are all factors that can contribute to a dog's stubborn behavior, impacting how successful training with remote collars can be.

What is the purpose of different levels of static correction in a collar?

Different levels of static correction allow you to adjust the intensity based on your dog's sensitivity and responsiveness. Most dogs respond well before reaching the highest level on the collar.

How effective are bark collars for stubborn dogs?

Bark collars can be effective for stubborn dogs, especially when combined with positive reinforcement training. However, effectiveness can vary depending on the dog's temperament and the specific issue being addressed.

What are the pros and cons of using a shock collar for stubborn dogs?

Pros can include quick results and the ability to control your dog at a distance. Cons may include potential physical harm or fear-based responses if not used correctly. It's important to get professional advice before using a shock collar.

What factors should be considered when buying a training collar for stubborn dogs?

Safety, your dog's size and temperament, your training goals, and the collar's range of effectiveness are crucial factors to consider. A collar that is safe, fits well, and aligns with your training goals will be the most effective

Thanks for reading!


Anxious Pup? The Power of Calming Collars for Dogs
Discover the transformative power of calming collars for dogs that mimic a mother’s nursing pheromones, creating a sense of tranquility & comfort.

Anxious Pup? The Power of Calming Collars for Dogs